Property Division Myths That Cause Stress (And What’s Actually True)

by | Jan 6, 2026 | Family Law

Property division is one of the most stressful parts of separation. But a lot of that stress comes from misunderstandings. In British Columbia, family law is clearer—and more fair—than most people realize.

Here are some of the most common property division myths we hear at Mather & Company, along with the truth behind them.

Myth 1: “Everything goes to whoever paid for it.”

Truth: If something was acquired during the relationship, it is usually shared—regardless of who paid for it or whose name is on the title.

This often includes:

  • Homes
  • Vehicles
  • Furniture
  • Investments
  • Pensions
  • Businesses

Ownership is based on when the property was acquired, not whose account or credit card was used.

Myth 2: “I’ll lose everything if I leave the home.”

Truth: Leaving the family home does not mean you give up ownership. Your legal interest in the property stays the same, even if you move out.

Myth 3: “Debts don’t get split.”

Truth: Debts are treated much like assets. If they were incurred during the relationship, they are usually shared—even if only one person’s name is on the account.

Myth 4: “My pre-relationship property stays fully mine.”

Truth: Property you owned before the relationship may be excluded, but any increase in value during the relationship is usually shared.

Myth 5: “We need court to divide property.”

Truth: Most families do not need to go to court. Property division can often be resolved through mediation or a written agreement.

How Property Is Divided in BC

British Columbia starts from a simple baseline: a 50/50 division of family property and family debt.

From there, adjustments can be made based on factors such as:

  • Each person’s needs
  • The needs of children
  • Fairness and practicality
  • Special or unique circumstances

What Makes Property Division Simpler

  • Calm, respectful conversations
  • Clear lists of assets and debts
  • Mediation support
  • Realistic expectations
  • Professional help with paperwork

How Mather & Company Supports You

We support clients through every stage of property division by helping with:

Property division does not have to feel overwhelming. With clear information and the right guidance, you can move forward with confidence, clarity, and fairness.

Contact Mather & Company today!

Contact Us

Call Us
Office: (250) 339-2902
Fax: (250) 890-9290

Email Us
reception@matherandcompany.ca

Address
Beaufort Professional Centre
306 – 1819 Beaufort Ave.
Comox, B.C., V9M 1R9

Our Reviews

Lorraine profile pictureLorraine
01:40 02 Aug 25
There aren't words to express how kind and helpful Gavin has been in preparing my dad's documents regarding his Will, Power of Attorney and medical advocacy.

After my dad putting it off for years, we left Gavin's office with huge smiles and a much deeper understanding of the various processes connected to ensuring my dad's health, finances, and my ability to represent and advocate for him are all in order.

His rate was great and his service was above and beyond. Thank you, Gavin!
Response from the owner 02:28 02 Aug 25
Thank you Lorraine, it was a pleasure helping you and your father. What a fantastic review, much appreciated!
Rebecca Mather profile pictureRebecca Mather
05:13 30 May 25
Gavin is personable, compassionate and truly listens to your concerns. Highly recommend as a lawyer.
Response from the owner 16:35 30 May 25
Thank you Rebecca
rick johns profile picturerick johns
03:43 26 May 25
Gavin is always very helpful and listens to me when I want him to do something that I feel needs to be done on top of what he is already doing.
He also gives great advice with his years of experience. Another thing I found with his office is that his staff is very knowledgeable compared to some other offices and Lawyers I’ve had to deal with before him, a pleasant experience.

I would no trouble recommending him to anyone else, and I have.
Response from the owner 23:23 27 May 25
Thanks Rick, myself and the team at Mather & Company appreciate your recommendation!
julius lumanta profile picturejulius lumanta
03:23 08 May 25
Mather and Company Family Law Firm provides compassionate, knowledgeable, and highly effective legal representation. Their team is attentive, thorough, and genuinely committed to helping clients navigate difficult family matters with clarity and confidence. Mather and Company delivers excellent service with integrity and professionalism.
Response from the owner 19:37 08 May 25
Thanks for the outstanding review Julius!
Amy Hollenbach profile pictureAmy Hollenbach
22:09 05 May 25
Working with Gavin was a wonderful experience. Highly recommend.
Response from the owner 02:31 06 May 25
Thank you Amy, appreciate you taking the time to share your experience with us.
Jan Grzeslo profile pictureJan Grzeslo
14:20 03 May 25
Gavin and his staff are very welcoming and professional. He accommodated my time constraints for a document that needed notarization promptly. Would highly recommend Gavin!
Response from the owner 02:30 06 May 25
Thank you!
Marlo McMurchy profile pictureMarlo McMurchy
15:05 02 May 25
I send clients to Gavin all the time and have only heard five star reviews. He is exactly what you need in a lawyer/mediator. Would recommend him and his amazing team to my closest relatives, which I think says something about his character.
Response from the owner 02:30 06 May 25
Very kind Marlo, thank you very much.
Seany Grogan profile pictureSeany Grogan
18:05 01 May 25
Very empathetic and understanding.

I Would highly recommend Gavin to anyone.
Response from the owner 02:30 06 May 25
Thank you for the recommendation.
Francesca Friesen profile pictureFrancesca Friesen
16:21 01 May 25
Gavin was compassionate, responsive, and deeply committed to the well-being of my family. I always felt heard, protected, and empowered throughout the process. I highly recommend him to anyone seeking a lawyer who is not only highly skilled but truly cares.
Response from the owner 02:29 06 May 25
Thank you for such a lovely review Francesca, we really appreciate it!
mslamontrichelle profile picturemslamontrichelle
15:17 01 May 25
Mather and Company were incredibly helpful when dealing with our remortgage! They went above and beyond to make sure everything went smoothly. Gavin is so friendly and professional. We will definitely be using their services for all of our family law needs! Highly recommend.
Response from the owner 02:28 06 May 25
Appreciate the kind review : )